EU Inc. will only work if founders choose it. Two major concerns with the Council’s 3rd compromise
EU Inc. will only succeed if entrepreneurs actually choose to use it. To be preferred over long-established national company forms or non-European flexible possibilities, it must be ambitious: simple, predictable and attractive from day one and all the way to exit. Only then can it become the legal form that helps Europe’s innovative companies grow across the Single Market and attract more and more investment, including from international investors. A watered-down EU Inc. would be an optional framework that few founders use, and it would fail to fulfil its purpose.
The ambition behind EU Inc. is European, not merely national. Its purpose is to enable companies to establish themselves, scale and attract investment in Europe, thereby supporting innovation, economic growth and employment across the Union. Its success must therefore be assessed against global competition for businesses, capital and talent, rather than solely through the balance between existing national legal frameworks.
Regulatory fragmentation is the main risk to this ambition. If EU Inc. becomes subject to overlapping national requirements, divergent interpretations or additional administrative obligations, it will reproduce the complexity it was designed to overcome. Every additional layer of complexity increases costs, reduces legal certainty and weakens Europe’s competitiveness as a whole, ultimately undermining its capacity to create and sustain jobs.
Business competitiveness and employee protection must not be presented as competing objectives. A successful EU Inc. should fully respect employees’ rights while enabling European businesses to grow, invest and create quality employment. The framework should be based on legal certainty, proportionality and mutual trust, rather than on a presumption that businesses seek to circumvent employee protections.
Against this background, the Council’s third compromise text of 16 October 2026 raises serious concerns, particularly regarding the following changes to the Commission’s original proposal, undermining the goal of making EU Inc. simple and attractive:
1. Employee participation in administrative or supervisory boards
The two previous compromise texts kept the principle that the employee participation rules of the Member State where the EU Inc. has its registered office would apply. The 3rd compromise keeps this principle but adds further constraints that risk fragmenting the applicable legal framework and that are consequently not acceptable.
Making EU Inc. law subject to the law of every Member State where the company operates (a kind of “contamination”), so that employees get equivalent rights, would create significant practical and legal difficulties. Such an approach would depart from the principle of a single applicable company law (the lex societatis) and could give rise to overlapping or potentially conflicting obligations. This would undermine legal certainty and predictability and increase compliance costs, particularly for companies seeking to expand across the Single Market.
The other option, requiring EU Inc. companies to set up subsidiaries in countries that have co-determination, would impose additional structural and administrative burdens that do not exist under current law. This could likewise potentially discourage cross-border activity and goes against simplification and attractiveness.
Both options would severely limit, if not entirely preclude, the use of EU Inc by entrepreneurs.
Directive (EU) 2019/2121, known as the Mobility Directive, already protects workers’ rights, and Article 12 of the Commission’s draft Regulation should provide the basis for ensuring that applicable employee participation rights are respected and that EU Inc. is not used to circumvent them. We oppose any employee participation in administrative or supervisory boards where it is not required by the national law of the Member State of the EU Inc.’s registered office or by the provisions of the Mobility Directive.
We therefore support a clear and predictable framework based on the law of the Member State in which the EU Inc has its registered office, subject to the applicable EU safeguards protecting employee participation rights. Additional obligations should not be introduced where they would create regulatory fragmentation or disproportionate constraints on cross-border growth.
2. Employee Stock Option Plan (EU-ESO)
The EU-ESO should be a key instrument for helping European companies attract, retain and reward talent by allowing employees to participate in the value they help create. Adding thresholds discourages growing companies from using the EU-ESO, because once they pass those thresholds they will have to switch to different national schemes. As a result, companies may be discouraged from adopting the scheme, which risks failing to gain traction from the outset.
This scheme is in no way a form of tax harmonisation. It does not touch the tax rate or the tax base, only the taxable event (when tax becomes due).
The changes in the 3rd compromise are a step back from the original goal of making EU Inc. attractive and predictable for the future. Companies need a stable and predictable framework throughout their development, not a mechanism that becomes more complex precisely when they begin to scale up. Fragmenting the EU-ESO would disadvantage both companies and employees. It would increase administrative costs, reduce the attractiveness of employee share ownership and weaken European companies' ability to compete internationally for talent.
The Commission's original proposal seeks to establish a common framework for employee equity incentives, including a harmonised approach to the timing of taxation, without harmonising national tax rates or tax bases. Any changes must preserve the legal and practical effectiveness of that objective, while respecting the applicable division of competences in taxation.
We therefore support maintaining an EU-ESO framework that is accessible to companies throughout their growth, without thresholds that force them into fragmented national arrangements.
Signatories:
- Asociación Española de Startups (AES), Carlos Mateo, President
- AI Austria - Ruben Hetfleisch, Board Member
- ANSA (Association nationale des sociétés par actions), Éric Sidot, Director General
- BESCO (Bulgarian Entrepreneurial Association), Alexander Nutsov & Mario Milev, Co-CEOs
- Czech Founders, Barbora Werdmölder, Director
- Danish Tech Startups, Esben Gadsbøll, Chairman
- European AI Forum (EAIF) - Daniel Abbou, President
- European Champions, Andrea Vaugan, Co-Founder & Secretary General
- France Digitale, Bettina Reveyron, Director General
- KI Bundesverband, Daniel Abbou, General Manager
- Les Entrepreneurs, Bruno Dondero, President of the Legal Commission
- Mouvement des Entreprises de France (Medef), Julien Guez, Directeur général
- iconomy, Felix Styma, Managing Director
- InnovUp, Giorgio Ciron, Director General
- Invest Europe, Eric de Montgolfier, CEO
- Italian Tech Alliance, Francesco Cerruti, Director General
- One Market, One Law, Michèle Grégoire, President
- Romanian Business Leaders Foundation, Alexandru Dincovici, General Director
- Startup Cyprus, Stavriana A. Kofteros, Co-founder and Chair
- Startup Greece, Thanos Paraschos, Managing Director